SORA

Advancing, promoting and sharing knowledge of health through excellence in teaching, clinical practice and research into the prevention and treatment of illness

Quantifying evidence for phenotypic specificity (PP4) for syndromic phenotypes: Large-scale integration of rare germline FH variants from diagnostic laboratory testing for HLRCC and renal cancer

Allen, S; Rowlands, CF; Butler, S; Durkie, M; Horton, C; Pesaran, T; Richardson, M; Robinson, R; Garrett, A; Burghel, GJ; et al. Allen, S; Rowlands, CF; Butler, S; Durkie, M; Horton, C; Pesaran, T; Richardson, M; Robinson, R; Garrett, A; Burghel, GJ; Callaway, A; Field, J; Frugtniet, B; Palmer-Smith, S; Grant, J; Pagan, J; McDevitt, T; Snape, K; Andreou, A; Maher, ER; Hanson, H; McVeigh, T; Turnbull, C; Jones, A-B; Reuther, A-M; Alder, A; Andreou, A; Ansari, A; Bench, A; Brady, A; Brittle, A; Callard, A; Callaway, A; Carter, A; Cartwright, A; Donaldson, A; Dunne, A; Garrett, A; Hadonou, A; Innes, A; Joshi, A; Kolozi, A; Kulkarni, A; Kumar, A; Logan, A; Lucassen, A; Luharia, A; May, A; Moleirinho, A; Murray, A; Ramsay Bowden, A; Ross, A; Sadan, A; Shaw, A; Singh, A; Taylor, A; Taylor-Beadling, A; Timbs, A; Visavadia, A; Webb, A; Whaite, A; Whitworth, A; Znaczko, A; Hogg, AC; Wallace, AJ; Wilsdon, A; Coad, B; DeSouza, B; Matharu, B; McIldowie, B; Mullaney, B; Pleasance, B; Speight, B; Torr, B; Andrews, C; Armstrong, C; Batterton, C; Bowles, C; Brewer, C; Brooks, C; Byrne, C; Cassidy, C; Clabby, C; Corbett, C; Crosby, C; Elliot, C; Forde, C; Garcia-Petit, C; Hayden, C; Huntley, C; Husher, C; Jenkins, C; Joyce, C; Lawn, C; Maurer, C; McCarthy, C; McKenna, C; McMullan, C; O’Brien, C; Olimpio, C; Ramsden, C; Rowlands, C; Sau, C; Shak, C; Sherlaw, C; Smith, C; Turnbull, C; Walsh, C; Watt, C; Wragg, C; O’Dubhshlaine, C; Babu, D; Baralle, D; Brown, D; Chubb, D; Donnelly, D; Goudie, D; Halliday, D; Lock, D; Martin, D; May, D; Moore, D; Navarajasegaran, D; Nocera-Jijon, D; Randhawa, D; Reay, D; Stobo, D; Ucanok, D; Wood, D; Wren, D; Evans, DG; Lobo, D; Eccles, DM; O'Sullivan, D; Atkinson, E; Baple, E; Cojocaru, E; Cross, E; Hanney, E; Higgs, E; Johnston, E; Maguire, E; Maher, E; Middleton, E; Mortensson, E; Petley, E; Petrides, E; Rauter, E; Rolf, E; Sofianopoulou, E; Wall, E; Woodward, E; Ali, F; Lalloo, F; McRonald, F; Pelz, F; Ryan, F; Sava, F; Baker, G; Corbett, G; Kavanaugh, G; Mullan, G; Nickless, G; Rea, G; Thodi, G; Burghel, GJ; Bezuidenhout, H; Carley, H; Clouston, H; Hanson, H; Heppell, H; Lindsay, H; Livesey, H; Massey, H; Northen, H; Powell, H; Reed, H; Warren, H; Whitehouse, H; Williamson, H; Thomas, HJW; Bhatnagar, I; Doal, I; Frayling, I; Tomlinson, I; Berry, IR; Barwell, J; Beasley, J; Bruty, J; Burn, J; Callaway, J; Campbell, J; Charlton, J; Cook, J; Davies, J; Del Rey Jimenez, J; Doughty, J; Dring, J; Drummond, J; Dunlop, J; Fairley, J; Field, J; Gabriel, J; Grant, J; Harper, J; Jaudzemaite, J; Jimmy, J; Mason, J; McLean, J; Murray, J; Oliver, J; Pagan, J; Peddie, J; Sampson, J; Sibbring, J; Sims, J; Spiers, J; Stevens, J; Tellez, J; Tolmie, J; Trotman, J; VanCampen, J; Whitworth, J; Willan, J; Williams, J; Bott, J; Andrews, K; Annesley, K; Asakura, K; Baker, K; Bean, K; Bradshaw, K; Brown, K; Cadoo, K; Ciucias, K; Cox, K; Doal, K; Edgerley, K; Gillespie, K; Jones, K; McKay Bounford, K; Mokretar, K; Monahan, K; Murphy, K; Oakhill, K; Oprych, K; Reay, K; Russell, K; Sahan, K; Smith, K; Snape, K; Stone, K; Tatton-Brown, K; Wall, K; Greenhalgh, K-L; Ong, KR; Alwadi, L; Busby, L; Chiecchio, L; Cobbold, L; Connolly, L; Crookes, L; Donaghy, L; Elmhirst, L; Freestone, L; Greensmith, L; Hanington, L; Hawkes, L; Hughes, L; Izatt, L; Jackson, L; Kearney, L; Kettle, L; Kiely, L; Kingham, L; Loong, L; Mavrogiannis, L; McSorley, L; Pearce, L; Pierson, L; Rainey, L; Reed, L; Sarkies, L; Side, L; Walker, L; Wang, L; Wilkinson, L; Worrillow, L; Yarram, L; Young, L; Sutton, LA; Ahmed, M; Bartlett, M; Bradford, M; Domeradzka, M; Duff, M; Durkie, M; Edis, M; Hegarty, M; Huxley, M; Khan, M; Kosicka-Slawinska, M; McConachie, M; Muraru, M; Owens, M; Ramos, M; Ryten, M; Shanmugasundaram, M; Slater, M; Slean, M; Smith, M; Tischkowitz, M; Tsang, M; Ukash, M; Watson, M; Chrysochoidi, N; Coleman, N; Elkhateeb, N; Gossan, N; Mannion, N; Orfali, N; Roberts, N; Walker, N; White, N; Woodwaer, N; Middleton, O; Taiwo, O; Tsoulaki, O; Alexopoulos, P; Angelini, P; Bowman, P; Brace, P; Dean, P; Logan, P; May, P; Moverley, P; Ostrowski, P; Tarpey, P; Wightman, P; Begum, R; Braham, R; Brown, R; Cleaver, R; Coles, R; Davidson, R; Harrison, R; Hart, R; Heron, R; Irving, R; Jeeneea, R; Kirk, R; Martin, R; Mitchell, R; Moore, R; Nyanhete, R; O’Shea, R; Patel, R; Robinson, R; Salmon, R; Sharmin, R; Tredwell, R; Wells, R; Wright, R; Abbs, S; Albaba, S; Allen, S; Aslam, S; Begum, S; Best, S; Borland, S; Botosneanu, S; Butler, S; Choi, S; Chu, S; Daniels, S; Dell, S; Ellard, S; Farndon, S; Greville-Heygate, S; Hardy, S; Hegarty, S; Heggarty, S; Lillis, S; Mackenzie, S; MacMahon, S; MacParland, S; McKee, S; Morosini, S; Mutch, S; Palmer-Smith, S; Prapa, S; Pryde, S; Pugh, S; Ribeiro, S; Samant, S; Shepherd, S; Talukdar, S; Taylor, S; Tennant, S; Thomas, S; Waller, S; Westbury, S; Bedenham, T; Campbell, T; Cranston, T; Foo, T; Langford, T; Linton-Willoughby, T; McDevitt, T; McVeigh, T; Tadiso, T; Cloke, V; Clowes, V; McConnell, V; Steventon-Jones, V; Tripathi, V; Cheah, W; Clinch, Y; Johnston, Y; Wallis, Y; Allen, Z; Hyder, Z; Kemp, Z (2025) Quantifying evidence for phenotypic specificity (PP4) for syndromic phenotypes: Large-scale integration of rare germline FH variants from diagnostic laboratory testing for HLRCC and renal cancer. Genetics in Medicine, 27 (11). p. 101565. ISSN 1098-3600 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gim.2025.101565
SGUL Authors: Andreou, Avgi Snape, Katie Mairwen Greenwood

[img] PDF Published Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.

Download (1MB)
[img] PDF (Supplementary Material) Supporting information
Download (407kB)
[img] Microsoft Excel (Supplementary_Tables1-7) Supporting information
Download (253kB)

Abstract

PURPOSE: Hereditary leiomyomatosis and renal cell cancer (HLRCC) is a rare cancer susceptibility syndrome exclusively attributable to pathogenic variants in FH (HGNC:3700). This article quantitatively weights the phenotypic context (PP4/PS4) of such very rare variants in FH. METHODS: We collated clinical diagnostic testing data on germline FH variants from 387 individuals with HLRCC and 1780 individuals with renal cancer and compared the frequency of "very-rare" variants in each phenotypic cohort with 562,295 population controls. We generated pan-gene very rare variant likelihood ratios (PG-VRV-LRs), domain-specific likelihood ratios for missense variants (DS-VRMV-LR) using spatial clustering analysis, and log2.08 likelihood ratios (LLRs) as applicable within the updated American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics/Association for Molecular Pathology variant classification framework. RESULTS: For HLRCC, the PG-VRV-LR was estimated to be 2669.4 (95% CI 1843.4-3881.2, LLR 10.77) for truncating variants and 214.7 (95% CI 185.0-246.9, LLR 7.33) for missense variants. For renal cancer, the PG-VRV-LR was 95.5 (95% CI 48.9-183.0, LLR 6.23) for truncating variants and 5.8 (95% CI 3.5-9.3, LLR 2.39) for missense variants. Clustering analysis in HLRCC cases revealed 3 "hotspot" regions wherein the DS-VRMV-LR increased to 1226.9. CONCLUSION: These data provide quantitative measures for very rare missense and truncating variants in FH, which reflect the differing phenotypic specificity of HLRCC and renal cancer and may be applicable in clinical variant classification.

Item Type: Article
Additional Information: © 2025 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. on behalf of American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Keywords: FH, Germline, HLRCC, Renal cancer, Variant interpretation
SGUL Research Institute / Research Centre: Academic Structure > Institute of Medical, Biomedical and Allied Health Education (IMBE)
Journal or Publication Title: Genetics in Medicine
ISSN: 1098-3600
Language: en
Media of Output: Print-Electronic
Related URLs:
Publisher License: Creative Commons: Attribution 4.0
Projects:
Project IDFunderFunder ID
BRC-1215-20014NIHR Cambridge Biomedical Research Centrehttps://doi.org/10.13039/501100018956
NIHR203312NIHR Cambridge Biomedical Research Centrehttps://doi.org/10.13039/501100018956
EDDPGM-Nov22/100004Cancer Research UKhttp://dx.doi.org/10.13039/501100000289
C61296/A27223Cancer Research UKhttp://dx.doi.org/10.13039/501100000289
PubMed ID: 40916913
Dates:
Date Event
2025-10-03 Published
2025-09-04 Published Online
2025-08-14 Accepted
Go to PubMed abstract
URI: https://openaccess.sgul.ac.uk/id/eprint/118024
Publisher's version: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gim.2025.101565

Actions (login required)

Edit Item Edit Item